Overview

Lick Ice Cream Indy is a standout destination for ice cream lovers in Indianapolis, nestled conveniently inside The Garage Food Hall at 906 Carrollton Ave. This shop delivers a refreshing twist on traditional frozen treats by offering a curated selection of around eight innovative flavors crafted with care and creativity.

Their menu features classics like Salted Caramel and Chocolate, but what truly sets Lick apart are the bolder choices such as Gorgonzola Candied Pecan and Pumpkin Five Spice Oatmeal Crisp. For those seeking plant-based options, the Vegan Rocky Road is a notable mention, showing their commitment to inclusivity. Offering both gelato and scoops served in cups or cones, they cater to varied preferences, making each visit feel tailored yet cohesive.

The experience here emphasizes quality and texture. Customers often highlight the rich creaminess and well-balanced flavors. Raspberry cheesecake and Gingersnap Lemon Curd come highly recommended for their delightful fusion of familiar yet unique tastes. The space itself is a cozy corner spot within the bustling food hall, ideal for individuals looking for a sweet reprieve amidst urban energy. Weekend crowds testify to its growing reputation among locals and visitors alike.

What resonates most about Lick Ice Cream Indy is their adventurous flavor approach paired with earnest craftsmanship. While some patrons wish for simpler variations, the shop excels in pushing boundaries without compromising the base quality. This balance appeals especially to those who appreciate an artisanal touch that respects tradition but isn’t afraid to experiment.

If you're a fan of ice cream shops that blend classic indulgence with inventive culinary sparks—and don’t mind a bit of vibrancy in your scoop—Lick Ice Cream Indy offers a memorable, flavorful experience worth exploring. Whether it’s a casual treat or an intentional tasting journey, this spot reflects the vibrant, creative spirit of Indianapolis’s evolving food scene.

For inquiries or orders, their contact number is +1 317-979-0237, and be prepared for a lively atmosphere, especially on weekends. Take your time sampling flavors that surprise and satisfy, making each visit a small adventure in frozen delight.


Amenities & Services

Popular for
Good for solo dining
Offerings
Serves coffee
Atmosphere
Casual
Trendy

What Customers Say

Nam Ssob
Dec 3,2025
4/5
Decent ice cream. Limited flavors, and their pumpkin should be renamed to Nutmeg ice cream, woah boy was that strong. Not my thing, but maybe someone else might like it.
N Surabhi
Dec 3,2025
5/5
Lick icecream is worth the hype. It’s one of the shops located inside The Garage. I tried their Munchies and Raspberry cheesecake flavours. Raspberry was heavenly. The texture is so rich and creamy, doing justice to the price being charged. I look forward to try more of their flavours
Anson Allseitz (Staff)
Dec 3,2025
5/5
I'm giving them 5 stars because they try hard and they make good stuff. You aren't going to regret anything you buy from them, honestly they are probably the best ice-cream makers in town. Personally I think they go a little too, "extra" with the flavours, AKA violet and cornbread... but even the extra ones taste great. My recommendation is to balance simplicity with pizazz. I would like to see things like raspberry chocolate chip or apple pie, aka simple flavours with spins. But again, what do I know? If the flower flavoured ice-cream works for y'all, who am I to say otherwise? Again, the ice cream tastes great.
Mark Midmark
Dec 3,2025
5/5
Stopped at the Lick Shop in the Indianapolis Garage Food Hall and had a few flavors. Buttermilk Sea Salt Brownie, Brown Sugar Cookie Dough, Gingersnap Lemon Curd, and Rosewater Pistachio Brittle. The Gingersnap Lemon Curd was my favorite, a soft lemon flavor with gingersnaps that had crystalized ginger pieces in it. All of the ice cream was creamy with more subdued flavors compared to the ones at Square Scoop, and while I preferred Square Scoop, I could see someone preferring Lick! Definitely check it out if you love ice cream, it was great.
sharanya chandran
Dec 3,2025
5/5
Definitely a must try place! Unusual flavours and very delicious. We tried Ginger lemon curd and Gorgonzola candied pecan, was just heavenly. I am already planning to grab some more later this week. Located inside Garage, a corner shop, definitely super crowded on weekends. They have around 8 flavours and of course cones , waffles reasonably priced. I wish they provide to-go boxes or lids for the icecream cups, will be much easier to just grab and go. Keep up the work team lick! Another visit , A pint of toffee wee mac, just delicious and couldn’t resist from buying gingersnap lemon curd again.
KatDJZ
Dec 3,2025
4/5
Love that they had a flight of 3 flavors so I got to try a few different ones. I also liked that they had some unique flavors, like lavender lemon and sweet corn. All were tasty!
Quintin Coppola
Dec 3,2025
4/5
Unique flavors at this stall in the Garage Food Hall. I tried the Gorgonzola Candied Pecan based on other reviews - the gingersnap lemon curd wasn't there when I went otherwise that would have been my pick. The Gorgonzola ice cream had a deep and rich dairy flavor, while the candied pecans gave a touch of sweetness and spice - very decadent but not too sweet. I gave 4-stars because I couldn't get a cone that day. I'm not entirely sure why but it was crossed off the board. I'd go back again to try something else (hopefully they have cones) but wouldn't make it a regular stop because of the parking situation - I don't want to pay to park to just get an ice cream cone.
Julie Zhu
Dec 3,2025
5/5
I always look forward to visiting this shop to explore their creative and unique flavors. The staff is patient and allows us to take our time sampling different options. The latest flavor I tried, Earl Gray Peppermint, was absolutely delightful! Highly recommend stopping by to see what new flavors they’ve come up with!

Leave a Review

Location

Opening Hours

Monday 12:00 PM - 09:00 PM
Tuesday 12:00 PM - 09:00 PM
Wednesday 12:00 PM - 09:00 PM
Thursday 12:00 PM - 09:00 PM
Friday 12:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Saturday 12:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Sunday 12:00 PM - 08:00 PM
Top Picks for You

More Ice Cream Shops in Indianapolis, Indiana, USA

Handpicked spots for food lovers. Your next favorite meal awaits!